Logo Logo
/// 
Bei Handball-Drehs: 50p oder 25p?

In handball shoot: 50p or 25p?



Frage von KrischanDO:
Januar 2010

Hi,

for handball club, I turn to s.and's Web Clips.
I ask myself: If I turn for a better presentation of clean motion with 50 frames or 25 frames? Cam: SonyEX-1
50 frames worth it? If it ere rendered on Youtube and Vimeo to 25 frames, right?
My calculator seems to be tormented with 720 50p material somewhat to 1080 25p geher much better.

Thank you for your advice!
Christian



Antwort von tommyb:

Tjo, good question.

Normally, one makes better sports photography with 50 images, because 25 can result in jerky movements. In your case, it should be a kind of image films? Then you yourself need to know whether the images that you can not rotate the avatar by 25p to Ruckelorgie.

If you still 50p rotate the avatar, you can after all still give out as 25p (every second frame omitted) and s.bestimmten bodies can the jerk a motion blur or the like to apply for these gentle movements. This could be you all at 25p material is not.



Antwort von Valentino:

@ KrischanDO

As 720p format should be with you with 50 or 25 fps, the first choice.
For this you can with the EX1, even with 60 frames to create / sec slow motion, arriving just really good at sports photography from the audience.
As long as it is only for synonymous interviews you can be happy with 25 frames to work, but 1080p with only 25 pictures just does not make sense in a sport like handball. With Full HD 1080 50i I'd completely forgotten s.deiner place, since each has Halblid only 540 instead of 720 lines.

That your calculator with 720 50p issue has surprised me but still very, since the computational cost is almost the same at 1080 50i is.
Just check times the frequency of your monitor. If the stand on 75 or 100Hz. If that does not help just write what times with Calculator / editing software you're working.

But as long as your calculator cope with 720 25p comes, if there were such a little trick. Draw the slow motion on the 720 25p mode, so the winner is the video clip of the play was with 50 images with 25 images.
The record with the 50 frames and, if appropriate, take a half away I hold only the amount of unnecessary work, with a careful planning of the filming can be prevented.








Antwort von KrischanDO:

@ Valtentino

Thank you for the detailed answer!

- Detailed planning of the shooting - haha ...
those are things like the city championship of the D-youth ...
As I sit in every game the team for our son next to the opponent's goal and hope do not get many nice Torwürfe on the cards and on the nose, and s.Seitenaus's own stores for a few nice parades in the gate of our son .. .
Since we are hunters and gatherers, not planners ...

I cut with Premiere Pro CS4 on Vista64, 8GB RAM, 2 x 3.0 GHz.
1x170 GB system disk, 1x650GB for photos, 1x650 GB for video.
Strangely, when I have to scrub the timeline, not a problem if it simply wants to play it, however, is, or jumps, the Picture, the sound is running next, premiere only delayed responding to the mouse.
Sometimes it runs better after emptying the media caches, sometimes synonymous spontaneously.

What actually remains of the 50p was left when it was processed at Youtube and Vimeo? Is rejected because every second frame? Or offset?

Regards
Christian



Antwort von Jott:

"With Full HD 1080 50i I'd completely forgotten s.deiner body"

This is what the vast majority of HD channels but different. Football World Cup, Olympics, athletics - everything 1080i50.



Antwort von Valentino:

"Jott" wrote:
"With Full HD 1080 50i I'd completely forgotten s.deiner body"

This is what the vast majority of HD channels but different. Football World Cup, Olympics, athletics - everything 1080i50.

Does not that completely. Such events are produced 50p/60p in 1080, because as good as any HD Studio Camera on Triax s.den such a signal can pass OB truck.
There, the signals are then stored on video servers and subsequently archived on HDCAM SR or DVCProHD.
The 1080 50p/60p is no Sendestandart is because the transfer is simply too costly, because the bandwidth in Comparison to 1080i resolution is twice as high.

For this reason, the public synonymous set to 720 out of 1080 50i and 50P.




Antworten zu ähnlichen Fragen:
Canon EOS R3: Aufnahmezeiten und Hitzelimits bei 6K 12 Bit 25p/50p RAW und 4K All-I 50p
'1080/25p All-Intra' bei gleicher Datenrate besser als '1080/50p All-Intra' ?
Canon EOS R5 ohne Hitzelimit bei 8K 25p und 5K 50p ProRes RAW mit dem ATOMOS Ninja V+ ?
Interview mit 2 Kameras aufgenommen (25p und 50p)
wie wandelt Resolve 50p Clips in einer 25p Timeline um?
Ready-To-Shoot Koffer für Einhandgimbals
Shoot on BMD
was sind die guten Projekteinstellungen bei 25p und 30p Videos
BenQ SW271C: 27" 4K Profi-Monitor mit 99% AdobeRGB und nativen 24P/25P/30P
Canon GX10 Panasonic x1500 24p 25p
Alphatron EVF 035W3G SDI Out flackert bei 50p
Premiere 2019: Keine 50p Anzeige mehr?
Panasonic S1: Autofokus- und 50p Slowmotion Test mit finaler 1.0 Firmwareversion
25i aus 50p in resolve
Die Panasonic S1H in der Praxis: Die neue Vollformat-Referenz? Hauttöne, 6K 10 Bit intern, 4K 50p 10 Bit - Teil 1
25 und 50p-Videomaterial mischen
DJI Mavic Air 2 im Praxistest: 4K 50p, D-Cinelike, neuer Controller - die bessere Mavic?
Panasonic S5 in der Praxis: Hauttöne, 10 Bit 50p intern, Gimbal-Betrieb, AF, LOG/LUT ? Teil 1
Canon EOS R6 im Praxistest - die bessere Alternative für 4K 10 Bit LOG 50p? - Teil1
ruckeln am TV bei 4K 50p
Insta360 ONE R bekommt ua. 50p-Option sowie Horizon Lock per neuer Firmware
Canon EOS R3 im Praxistest: 12 Bit 6K RAW 50p, Hauttöne, LOG/LUT, Stabilisierung, DJI RS2 uvm ?
DJI Mavic 3 Cine: Erstes Hands-On inkl. Cine-Setup mit 5.1K ProRes HQ 50p LOG

















weitere Themen:
Spezialthemen


AI
ARD
AVCHD
AVI
Adobe After Effects
Adobe Premiere Pro
After effects
Apple Final Cut Pro
Audio
Avid
Avid Media Composer
Cam
Camcorder
Camera
Canon
Capture
Capturing
Clip
EOS
Editing
Effect
Error
Film
Final Cut
Format
HDR
Import
JVC
Layer
Light
MAGIX video deLuxe
Magix
Microphone
Movie
Panasonic
Pinnacle
Pinnacle Studio
Premiere
RAM
RED
Recording
Software
Sony
Sound
Studio
TV
Video
Videos