Logo Logo
/// 
XL2 vs. 5D MK2

XL2 vs. 5D MK2



Frage von schlappen:
August 2010

Dear brethren,

After long consideration, I have now decided not to me synonymous finally a Canon 5D MK2 of zuzulegen. That means I have it yet, but it has already ordered the photo dealer I trust.
I have been photographed with her and held synonymous already in the hands of the shooting, a great part.

So far I have an XL2 called my own or do I still do. But see, I do not play with the 5D rosy times more on my good old mill. What light, sensor, Lenses regard, it can not keep up with the 5D in my opinion and my needs to. The only drawback is of course the Tonspeisung. Since the XL2 is of course far superior.

Now my idea, I keep my old baby or I will separate myself for financial reasons of her? What do you think? XL2 vs. 5D: What are the advantages and disadvantages? Is it worth an XL2 at all next to a 5D?

Kind regards,
Tim



Antwort von gast3:

until we know what you want to do ", you will be hard to guess .... are two entirely different things, but now wish you a lot of fun getting used to the convenient handling of a Viedeocam, to more elaborate, in any case Working with a DSLR.
SD and HD are synonymous different worlds, as I said, if you do not know your field of work .....



Antwort von B.DeKid:

I had 3 x XL1s and have only sold one and kept the other two remain - for certain things is (are used) is still great.

I would then decide whether you s.deiner body really need the money, and if not I would just keep the XL2.

Why do you want to buy one but two years aqlte Cam (5D Mark II) I do not quite understand?

MfG
B. DeKid








Antwort von schlappen:

What do I do it "" will, it simultaneously as a still camera and video camera to use it as synonymous. I just put in the beginning, not just a hobby but synonymous to advance professionally in the movie business. For ages I have been interested with photography and film. Unfortunately, the big lottery windfall has so far been made and therefore was and my financial framework is unfortunately very limited. Currently, I get on with work experience in copying works of rum and film equipment rental companies, its equivalent in income tends to be more synonymous therefore null.

With the 5D I had a camera, which both my photography and Stillimage synonymous my cinematic ambitions may also cover satisfactorily. Bildqualitativ it is all the classes of higher quality than my current DSLR. And synonymous filmmäßig she has some significant advantages over my XL2, which I do not think irrelevant. The superior low-light quality to me is not just a technical bells and whistles, but once synonymous with saving money properly connected. The low-light properties of the XL2 are unfortunately far from exceptional. Accordingly, a higher light burden of distress, more lights, more power, more money! Also filming on location, with available light at dusk (with the intention of synonymous nor what to see the other side of the sky) is on the XL2, unfortunately, just wishful thinking. With the 5D in turn create quite.

Another big advantage is the Sensorgroße in full format. This gives you a completely different depth than the XL2 allows. A 35mm adapter, the XL2 provides relief, of course, but swallows the back lots s.Licht synonymous and thus require especially for indoor shots nochmehr light capacity.

FullHD vs. SD is of course a common Comparison. Depending on the application, SD is quite sufficient.

The is just getting used s.Anfang certainly very difficult. I expect, however, already so, I acquire a shoulder stand and FollowFocus to the handling simpler. The smaller and lighter the camera, the more jerky, of course, synonymous. However, it is difficult to find for the XL2 to an inexpensive and yet good Tripod. Had I been even a Manfrotto Tripod 700 ¬ to them, or had already failed the first test, however hopeless. While it was for max. 5.5 kg interpreted, but the resilience and determination of the screws in at the weight of the XL2 failed just 4.2 n.völlig. So exchange. So to get one but probably Sachtlerstativ, but there try something clever for under 1000 ¬. And here we are again reached the Money Factor.

When combined camera the 5D MK2 is not a good choice. Sure, 2 years ago it was the first time on the Thresen, but it is outdated and thus bad? Do you have an alternative for me? One that does not cost ¬ 4,000 more?

Thank you for your answers



Antwort von gast3:

for the Canon 5D you will also need a (very good) tripod, I would orfeigen me when this s.sich very good material is blurred, because with a shoulder stand fabricated "." (I know, not all can be a bulky use tripod) But why do so many people are suddenly just the most important accessories for the shooting of Scots, I do not understand anyway, thousands Euronen for a Cam, but the tripod: to be a little less like?

A common use of both of these cams (in a Project) is probably not because of the resolution differences be vorteihaft ....



Antwort von schlappen:

Of course, is utter bullshit. I have never talked about wanting to put my camera on a cheap tripod. I do not know whether you make movies himself. If so you should be aware with certainty that not everything can be rotated by the tripod must / should / may. Only of the shoulder should be rotated material without an appropriate tripod with the 5D more difficult. And right of the hand rotated can not till quite forgotten. Head on and then your mouth.
My goodness this is a difficult forum. Here, everyone respects to God.




Antworten zu ähnlichen Fragen:
Sony RX100 MK2 Hot Shoe Audio zubehör
On-Camera Monitor TVLogic F-7H mk2: 3.600 nits hell und verbessert // NAB 2019
Überarbeitete Samyang VDSLR MK2 Objektive ab Herbst, low-budget und auch mit RF-Mount
Samyang MK2 Infos?
Weitwinkel Cine-Objektiv Samyang MF 14mm T3,1 erscheint in der VDSLR MK2 Serie
Samyang VDSLR MK2 Cine-Objektive jetzt auf für Canon RF-Mount
Denver ac-5000w mk2 als webcam
Vergleich Batis 85mm und Samyang 85mm T1.5 MK2
Samyang 135mm T2,2 VDSLR MK2 erweitert die überarbeitete Cine-Reihe
Samyang Festbrennweite VDSLR MK2 oder Sony 28 - 135 f4 OSS
Neue Angelbird AV PRO CFexpress MK2 Type B mit 4 TB und 1.300 MB/s Schreibgeschwindigkeit
Gerüchte zu Panasonics Lumix S1H II (Mk2) - 8K mit 60p und ProRes RAW

















weitere Themen:
Spezialthemen


16:9
AI
ARD
AVCHD
AVI
Adobe After Effects
Adobe Premiere Pro
After effects
Apple Final Cut Pro
Audio
Avid
Avid Media Composer
Cam
Camcorder
Camera
Canon
Capture
Capturing
Clip
EOS
Editing
Effect
Error
Export
File
Files
Film
Final Cut
Format
Formate
HDR
Import
JVC
Layer
Light
MAGIX video deLuxe
Magix
Microphone
Monitor
Movie
PC
Panasonic
Pinnacle
Pinnacle Studio
Player
Premiere
RAM
RED
Recording
Red
Software
Sony
Sound
Studio
TV
Tape
Video
Videos