Logo Logo
/// 
Apple oder Normaler PC für die Videoberabeitung

Apple or PC for the Normal Videoberabeitung



Frage von masterkillmore:
Januar 2006

Have I gained not so long ago, the SonyHDR-HC1.
and use my PC (AMD Athlon 64 3200Ghz, 1024MB Ram, Geforce 6800, DVD Burner +) to view the videos on hard drive to attract. The synonymous works wonderfully. But I have learned that many skilled craftsmen to use Apple's Calculator their videos to cut. So for me the following questions arise.

Is it worth something that is actually a relatively-new calculator for sale to fetch a MAC too?

Which Apple machines to process well enough to be able to HDTV?

Benny



Antwort von PowerMac:

Your PC is fast enough.

You'd have much rather spend money to come to a similar performance. Say a dual-core PowerMac s.2000 euros. (where each software is different fast)

The benefits include OS X, Final Cut Studio and the design.
Schau doch mal in macuser.de pure. There, some 42,000 German Macuser are logged in, which can perhaps convince you of the benefits. Before thousands of other people here say that you need a Mac to film cutting and that it is subjective, with what software, and you cut the same way that Vegas is great. Right. And? If there is a grave next to you or Comspot shop there, look clean and ask for a crash course through the system, and Computer Programs.



Antwort von MiXMaster:

here is after a gain videoschnitt hdv asked. I think of as synonymous pc-user, this is the mac with FinalCutPro this ...








Antwort von Christian Schlögel:

"Anonymous" wrote:
here is after a gain videoschnitt hdv asked. I think of as synonymous pc-user, this is the mac with FinalCutPro this ...


Justification?



Antwort von PowerMac:

The price, the test results, the use of Hollywood films and many production companies.



Antwort von Christian Schlögel:

"PowerMac" wrote:
The price, the test results, the use of Hollywood films and many production companies.


Hmm. I do not think that that alone is sufficient to claim that this is the "better" choice? At the price I have my doubts synonymous so ;-)
I read in many reviews, that the PC and enter the MAC in terms not much and it is ultimately a matter of taste. Or in other words: What can I do with the MAC, which I with a PC-based system can not?



Antwort von tvschaumburg:

I just want to note the following times on the price. (I use a Mac to cut übrigends Dual 2.2)

What do you get for the money if you sold the PC after a year and there's what you get for a Mac? The Mac lost more than 60% of the value of a PC can almost throw away the store before he ever really leave.

It will certainly be more expensive to buy, but we say, I'm loading times 1000 minutes then I had the mac does not misfire when you import a picture, I think that's synonymous a way to describe the differences, but since you now have ever seen a computer would I'll recommend him only once and use it as described above have been times in just go to an Apple Store and just look at.



Antwort von PowerMac:

"PowerMac" wrote:
The price, the test results, the use of Hollywood films and many production companies.


Refers to whether it is professional.



Antwort von MiXMaster:

"tvschaumburg" wrote:
I just want to note the following times on the price. (I use a Mac to cut übrigends Dual 2.2)

What do you get for the money if you sold the PC after a year and there's what you get for a Mac? The Mac lost more than 60% of the value of a PC can almost throw away the store before he ever really leave.

It will certainly be more expensive to buy, but we say, I'm loading times 1000 minutes then I had the mac does not misfire when you import a picture, I think that's synonymous a way to describe the differences, but since you now have ever seen a computer would I'll recommend him only once and use it as described above have been times in just go to an Apple Store and just look at.


Well then wait times, which is in a year when suddenly declared Uncle Steve: ooch, we have not yet supporten next block over the PPC to who wants new features in the software, must stop a new Intel-based buying Powermac. The fact is precisely the company's policy, you'd expect from Apple, and one must be a prophet to foresee that the priority will be to develop new software on the future Intel chips - what do you mean what with the prices of second hand G5's will happen? Viewed apart from that, the G5's unbdingt not a miracle what energy efficiency is concerned (on the contrary: Quote of the Apple Page: At least 10A (low-voltage range) or 5A (high-voltage range) - not of poor parents, which that blows, synonymous when it is certainly not a permanent condition) and for this reason alone I would buy at this stage with the G5 Powermac no longer synonymous if the price Quadsystem can convince (Performance-synonymous).

Also, if you place such comparisons compare, then please synonymous with the same same: an HP workstation, of course, loses synonymous s.wert less than a 0815 Discount PC. Apple is only the style-factor supplement to this is - eh no negligible factor in the brand (product placement is first class from Apple - you'd think there would be nothing if you look closely current movies).

Incidentally, I have no dropouts synonymous on the PC while recording - is nothing macspezifisches ;-).

@ Powermac

Which Hollywood film has been realized with Final Cut Pro? Check out the DVD's time to credits at the end, what do you see? Correct, in the overwhelming number of cases probably the Avid logo, because there are Avid systems in the industry is still dominated and FC s.and times s.vielleicht synonymous when used, it has nowhere near the spread, such as Avid systems.

My opinion: Change is now a Mac to the worst possible time, because the future security of the G5's seem more than questionable. Professinoneller with the Mac, you will certainly not synonymous, synonymous if Final Cut Pro is certainly a good program. That many companies are working on Macs (especially in the studio, graphics) can be justified historically - formerly the Macs were more stable and reliable in Comparison to the PC's, what was certainly true synonymous - in the meantime, however, is no longer tenable and If I read the Mac Forums transversely to fight there with similar problems, such as the PC world, but we must learn as Macuser deal with the problems, since it has fewer alternatives :-).

Greeting
January



Antwort von masterkillmore:

After all, what I have heard things seem s.interessanten AVID LIVE one Konkurent to Final Cut Pro to be. Or Maybe it is better?

Greeting

Benny



Antwort von mdb:

"masterkillmore" wrote:
After all, what I have heard things seem s.interessanten AVID LIVE one Konkurent to Final Cut Pro to be. Or Maybe it is better?


Better? I can not say I only know of AVID. This is a professional editing program, no preference on whether MAC or PC based.



Antwort von Flash:

"tvschaumburg" wrote:
I just want to note the following times on the price. (I use a Mac to cut übrigends Dual 2.2)

What do you get for the money if you sold the PC after a year and there's what you get for a Mac? The Mac lost more than 60% of the value of a PC can almost throw away the store before he ever really leave.

It will certainly be more expensive to buy, but we say, I'm loading times 1000 minutes then I had the mac does not misfire when you import a picture, I think that's synonymous a way to describe the differences, but since you now have ever seen a computer would I'll recommend him only once and use it as described above have been times in just go to an Apple Store and just look at.


Funny. I buy hardware with the intent to best fulfill my duties and not in order as far as the resale value. Otherwise you can buy any software s.sowieso more, because that is after 1-2 years synonymous worthless and b), Digicams, DVD recorder, simply almost everything from consumer electronics. The clutter is so quickly outdated and falls off the price.

And what was the picture with the dropouts? The problem I had never before, but I will after you mentioned it, eighth time in the future on it ... ;-)
No offense - Flash








Antwort von MiXMaster:

No, I do not think you can say this:

Avid was a pioneer in digital nonlinear editing systems and has thus synonymous high penetration levels in the industry (has virtually established an industry standard). No matter what channel you look, Avid can start with what the people and once you've become on an Avid system, this is synonymous reluctant to miss.
This refers not to the pure software solution, but on the associated hardware. A look at the price list then synonymous illustrates that it is not Final Cut Pro can be compared with a Media Composer - there are about 20 k euro price difference between them.

The advantage of Final Cut Pro is, in my opinion, is that the software is open to third-party hardware (Avid) is not what makes the bundle of Mac OS / Software + converter boards actually considerably cheaper than bsp. one Adrenaline HD system. Whether that is comparable in quality, I dare not judge.

If you want something to compare the two Manufacturer, you would have with Final Cut Pro, Xpress Pro (which would be comparable to the solution of Avid NLE without hardware for PC / Mac) - but there's as many opinions as relating to Mac or PC. Whether FC Avid killer is really the future remains to be seen - Avid itself certainly is not synonymous asleep.

Greeting
January



Antwort von Captain Kirk:

I am a PC user, and let me build the hardware section, but it is to get the services of a s.The Minimacs up to be (440 Euro plus VAT) had at least inverstieren the 3-fold + software. The Minimac is already equipped with video software (iMovie) and you immediately can start it.

To cut nearly as well as tvSchaumburg with the same performance of an Apple system, I mus invest pro Calculator between 5000 and 10000 euros ...
With nem Aldi machine is it not done ....



Antwort von ricky2000:

I'm glad to have a PowerMac.
Whether it is for someone with a relatively new and powerful PC's worth changing, I can not judge, but I am very satisfied.
The PowerMac G5 will be replaced until around mid-2007 through IntelMacs, therefore, of the still far from in front of the stand.
In addition, a working system is not useless just because there is something newer.
Examples of Final Cut Pro to cut such films would be The Lord of the Rings trilogy (if I remember correctly).
And as long as the majority of the pro-user has not even committed G4 and G5, they are not of the software industry boycotted.
Until the x86 Macs are in the majority, will still take years.



Antwort von Roma:

Hier gehts but in the ever-present question, came first the chicken or the egg? Respectively. And now Is the theory of evolution according to Darwin, or at least everything is in divine creation (on this subject is broken currently but in fact) a court in the United States the head.

PC or MAC? If no preference yet! Use of the system just yet, in which you feel you well! Which is true of the workflow. Finally Throws thoughts on an even faster, more perfect and more professional system to pieces! Ifs to be really professionel, you rent a studio for a project in one and takes you a professional cutter, the systems on the Avid-based there will cost well over ¬ 10,000.

For myself, I am of a homemade SuperPower Win system, with perverse switched memory and Premiere Pro on an I-Mac with FinalCut Express and do not regret this ninth second. Not a crash or blue screen gibts (yes on OSX do not). When Win system, I've racked my head just about dopey expansion opportunities and performance, instead of sitting around on movie ideas. And honestly, how many% of us have actually been times Videoholics Professor used the power of a system? Rather, there is but on the content of the film on it, as when the power cut.

Roger




Antworten zu ähnlichen Fragen:
Linsenreflektionen normal?
Filmscanner für Super und normal 8
[WinTV PVR 150] - "mechanische" Bildwiedergabe - normal?
Pinnacle Studio 10 Plus: Bild läuft zu schnell, Ton normal :(
Apple: Neues 7K Studio Display mit integriertem Apple Silicon in Entwicklung?
Die Highlights der Apple WWDC: iOS 12, Apple TV 4K mit Dolby Surround, macOS Mojave
Apple
Apple Event…
RED vs. Apple
Clip für Apple
Apple *.DV -> Windows *.AVI
Apple 8K Professional Camera
Apple Show time (not)
Apple Event Frühling 2021
Apple Bechleunigerkarten für alle?
Apple kauft VR/AR-Startup Vrvana
Apple Motion Freelancer gesucht
Apple M2 Chips in der Mache
Brief History on Apple ProRes RAW
Apple Live Stream - neues iPhone 12
Apple iPhone Xs - Bildqualität beim Filmen in 4K
Blender 2.93.0 Alpha für Apple M1 verfügbar
Apple Pro Display XDR genaue Größe?
Arbeitet Apple an einer Drohne? Patente eingereicht ?
Asynchron mit Bmpc4k Apple ProRes 422 HQ
Apple M2 Pro wird nochmals deutlich leistungsstärker

















weitere Themen:
Spezialthemen


16:9
AI
ARD
AVCHD
AVI
Adobe After Effects
Adobe Premiere Pro
After effects
Apple Final Cut Pro
Audio
Avid
Avid Media Composer
Cam
Camcorder
Camera
Canon
Capture
Capturing
Clip
EOS
Editing
Effect
Error
Export
File
Files
Film
Final Cut
Format
Formate
HDR
Import
JVC
KI
Layer
Light
MAGIX video deLuxe
Magix
Microphone
Monitor
Movie
PC
Panasonic
Pinnacle
Pinnacle Studio
Player
Premiere
RAM
RED
Recording
Red
Software
Sony
Sound
Studio
TV
Tape
Video
Videos