Logo Logo
/// 
Canon HG20 oder Sony SR11

Canon HG20 or SonySR11



Frage von FilmMaker:
April 2009

Hello dear community,

I would like to be a small Full HD Cam growth.

According to some reports, I now Schwanke between the Canon HG20 and the SonySR11. Both tests have a TOP-Picture, good sound, 60 GB hard drive and what for me is also important, both can still record to external memory. The stupid thing is only the Sonyauf memory stick pro duo recording, the considerably more expensive than regular memory are included in the Canon Cam come.

I need a cam, which still synonymous in dark scenes such as in clubs makes a good figure. Work otherwise with the Canon XL H1, but can not really serve as a comparison, but I have always driven well with Canon.

What is your opinion on the two cams? Vll anyone ever had both in hand and can say that Cam is better?

Thanks in advance.



Antwort von actaion:

"Film Maker" wrote:

The stupid thing is only the Sonyauf memory stick pro duo recording, the considerably more expensive than regular memory are included in the Canon Cam come.


True, this is a disadvantage of the Sony. Since you but a 60GB hard-drive in it with hats, you need not have vast amounts s.Kartenspeicher. In this respect, I would of the few euros more for a SDHC to MS's decision not addictive.

"Film Maker" wrote:

What is your opinion on the two cams? Vll anyone ever had both in hand and can say that Cam is better?


Which you like better in your hand, you can only judge myself.

"Film Maker" wrote:

I need a cam, which still synonymous in dark scenes such as in clubs makes a good figure. Work otherwise with the Canon XL H1


At the XLH1 both are probably not rankommen.
The Sonyliegt but the advantage here because they have the Night Shot function. In many clubs are you at no additional lighting is often aufgeschmissen otherwise.



Antwort von jonnyy2b:

Allso I did for 1 week only!) The SR11 and am over Picture and Sound so what of enthusiasm that I could cheer. Previously I had a JVC GR gz505, which of course is a bad comparison.
When I at the MM compared Cams I can against the dark surroundings only say that the Sony Initially little more noisy, but the Canon has at reflecting surfaces in the dark vertical lines then hingestrahlt.
The SD cards for the Canon represents only an SD recording with resolution 1440 x 720er possible, so to get more expensive SDHC s.den not synonymous over. With ebay, I have a Memory Pro Duo 4GB for 17Eur fetched, works flawlessly. Mach hauptsächl since. my pictures.
What I actually did not knew, this is with the NIGHT SHOT functions. With the SR11 can shoot in complete darkness and then noticed the really synonymous None! The IR lamp shines really well from three meters (maybe not quite evenly) The films, however, have a greenish tint. However, there are three stages between depending on the brightness.
Such a "picture" of what weak light, I have at least 1000 Cam None of view. The Canon will perhaps even slightly better, but its dynamic behavior is much more sensitive.
The absolute Knaller s.der SR11 however, I would like finally to mention, these are the absolute and the real colors in the spring just can not Canon or Panasonic. Even in the gray in gray MM are very exaggerated.

Maybe I could still young in some little experience to help you. viellecht you need for your system operations closer look dark when making comparisons because both the real advantage lies.








Antwort von henric-a:

@ jonny,

may I ask where you bought the SR11 searched and how much you've paid. Does she want me synonymous since 4 weeks and waiting for pick at the moment only that the price goes back down.

Thank you very much
Henric



Antwort von jonnyy2b:

Do I, as described above, by German Office shop. The synonymous lasted nearly 3 weeks until there was and the price went up every day to 739th I 659EU paid 17EU + 4GB Card + NP70 Battery Charger 23EU + 10EU because I save the Cam möcht. Two days later she was in Germ. sold out.
I can only recommend world of electronik, where she still 689EU costs and recently was 7 s.Lager had.
Wiklich This is a nice Famileineunternehmen what I call herausgehört had. Because I would fastest strike.

jonnyy2b



Antwort von henric-a:

Hates you da ne url, have already gegoogelt the day but found nothing.

Thank you very much
Henric



Antwort von jonnyy2b:

The website has world-of-electronik.de / Hope that you still get ne Cam, which is now back on 699Eu high. In the case where the price was already synonymous with the 679th --
Could so with a possible purchase mention me?
Were at least super if you could again report whether and how the business is gone.

Greetings and have fun acting.



Antwort von henric-a:

@ all

So I did my Page called the jonnyy2b has angeguckt times. It costs the cam 699, - BUT this is the same seller, dier few weeks before the Cam at Ebay has vertickt.

Did the then approached the wanted my email address, so he sent me the link for his online store, can hmm then had me look at the link you can give.

Then I page through their provider, the call back service is used and the last days s.Tag repeatedly tried to reach the phone.

What I'm saying here is, the whole comes to me very strange. You can reach no one who does not receive any answers to written questions, etc.

So I'm careful and do not, is synonymous that you ONLY pay by prepayment, it is me in the background too hot.

Henric



Antwort von jonnyy2b:

Yes that's true, this is the same as for Internet Schopen ebay, I am synonymous to come. Times since I've called and talked with his wife, both of which are working and only in the early stages. I have around 17Uhr went directly to the phone and gave me the direct website called, where she then was synonymous cheaper.
Since they are often inundated mails, they hardly respond to the standard and therefore send out mails.

I found her very honest and trusting, more than German Office, where I never again will buy what and when then only by surnames. The time has had the best offer.

In addition, I was in Tunisia 2Wochen and did a lot gefilm. Getstern I came to me a couple of film clips and view the Picture s.großen TV with the sea and the sandy walls and tanned guide is the hammer! What a sharpness!
The Backlight button is synonymous s.richtigen place and function in the class. The faces s.Strand with Backlight ausgeleuchtetr well and the rest is not too bright and turned around just super!




Antworten zu ähnlichen Fragen:
Canon HG20 arbeitet nicht im Aufnahmemodus
Externes Mikro für alte Canon HG20 oder Sony Alpha7
Canon Roadmap 2017: 4K Canon EOS C100 MK III zur NAB?
GoPro passend zu Canon XA20 und Canon LEGRIA HF30
GoPro passend zu Canon XA20 und Canon LEGRIA HF30
Verringert 4K-Crop für Canon R -- neuer 0.71x Metabones Speedbooster Canon EF auf RF
Canon EOS Kameras als Webcam mit neuer Beta Software von Canon
Canon auf der NAB 2018: Canon EOS C100 MKIII vs Vollformat Spiegellose ?
Messevideo: Canon Sumire - erste Canon Vollformat Cine Objektivserie mit PL Mount // NAB 2019
Canon HF100 VS. Canon PowerShot SX530 HS
Unterschied Canon xa 20 und Canon hf g30
24 fps für Canon EOS RP und Canon EOS 90 D als freies Firmware-Download verfügbar
Canon 100-400 an C300 (war: Canon C300 PL auf EF umbauen?)
Neue Canon Objektive: RF 15-35mm F2.8L IS USM, RF 24-70mm F2.8L IS USM und besserer Augen-AF für Canon EOS R und RP
Canon HG 20
Canon XL 1
Canon HV 20
Canon 5D mark3
Canon EOS R
Canon Ixus 40
Canon 80D ?
CANON C70
Canon EOS 5D 2
Canon HV 30 Datenübertragung
Canon FD zu EF - Umbau
Canon MVX250i

















weitere Themen:
Spezialthemen


16:9
ARD
AVCHD
AVI
Adobe After Effects
Adobe Premiere Pro
After effects
Apple Final Cut Pro
Audio
Avid
Avid Media Composer
Cam
Camcorder
Camera
Canon
Capture
Capturing
Clip
EOS
Editing
Effect
Error
Export
File
Files
Film
Final Cut
Format
Formate
HDR
Import
JVC
Layer
Light
MAGIX video deLuxe
Magix
Microphone
Monitor
Movie
PC
Panasonic
Pinnacle
Pinnacle Studio
Player
Premiere
RAM
RED
Recording
Red
Software
Sony
Sound
Studio
TV
Tape
Video
Videos