Logo Logo
/// 
Canon XH-A1 vs. Sony HVR-V1E?

Canon XH-A1 vs. SonyHVR-V1E?



Frage von pailes:
August 2008

Halli Hallo,

I would like now after a long think about it synonymous times an HD Cam treat. In the price category that appeals to me, but there are already several models, especially stand out here the Canon XH-A1 and the SonyHVR-V1E envisaged.

I already have a Canon XM-1 and had a few years ago, unfortunately, problems with the drive ( "Remove Cassette" problem), what makes me 350 ¬ repair has cost. A friend had the same period with his VX2K in terms of little problems, so I Canon meanwhile become'm somewhat skeptical, although I have manual setting possibilities of XH-A1 is already extremely address. (The Canon cameras make me always a little "fragile" impression I formed a?)

And there still would be the 3xCCD vs. 3xCMOS, although it seems that Canon delivers a better picture.

I'm grateful for any comments.



Antwort von Axel:

At what conclusion you come from, is up to you, but all factors are properly evaluated, from my point of view (by chance know of any models that were mentioned here, but would say that the VX2k is not good compared with the XM1 and still better than the XM2 ).



Antwort von pailes:

"Axel" wrote:
... know all the random models, which have been mentioned here, but would say that the VX2k is not good compared with the XM1 and still better than the XM2.

Since you have right, of course, the XM-1 and the VX2k then played mainly synonymous priced in a completely different league. Nevertheless, I was very disappointed as I was when the error on the internet found many similar problems. And if I am now at the XH-A1 to read reports on dropouts, can I get an uneasy feeling in the stomach area.

I'm on synonymous Subjective opinions appreciated. I hope my soon to a dealer to make your own picture to be.





Antwort von r.p.television:

I think with the XH A1 and XL H1 always synonymous, the same tapes (and ideally then synonymous Panasonic) is used, no problem should arise. So it is in any case two years ago with my two Canon cameras (XH A1 and XH H1 = identical drive).
Others have come to the realization came.
And if Sony does not take premium.
My XH A1 in any case represents a very strong impression and has about 30 vollgefilmten cassette until now neither "Remove the Cassette" or conspicuously produced many dropouts.
And here I prefer the comparison to the PD150, which I had before.



Antwort von masterseb:

I still think that with the sony V1E will be happier. Silver Support is not beating. also is the 25p mode and the functional slomo interesting. cons: no internal and external micro is optional accessories. canon makes crispy bild ... at first glance only. cmos I think is best. with bands I had never in my xha1 problems, I had almost everything: Sony HDV, DV fuji, canon dv / HDV and panasonic.



Antwort von pailes:

"masterseb" wrote:
... also is the 25p mode and the functional slomo interesting.

The XH-A1 so synonymous has a 25p mode, this is in comparison to Sonyminderwertig?



Antwort von masterseb:

canon offers 25F, which is a pseudo p-mode. The format can only be of the s.lesen not conform with the standards.



Antwort von pailes:

"masterseb" wrote:
canon offers 25F, which is a pseudo p-mode. The format can only be of the s.lesen not conform with the standards.

This is indeed an interesting information, because until now I thought, these modes would be roughly equivalent. And when should I V1E still an external Microphone most?



Antwort von masterseb:

so it is.



Antwort von Axel:

"masterseb" wrote:
canon offers 25F, which is a pseudo p-mode. The format can only be of the s.lesen not conform with the standards.
But standard. The HDV standard is 1440x1920, and which is defined as interlaced. Ultimately, therefore, the V1 uses the same trick in the recording, such as the A1, two simultaneous fields (alternative expression: No Halbbilddominanz) than full pay. The difference is that the progressive Sonydiese synonymous's.




Antworten zu ähnlichen Fragen:
Canon Roadmap 2017: 4K Canon EOS C100 MK III zur NAB?
GoPro passend zu Canon XA20 und Canon LEGRIA HF30
GoPro passend zu Canon XA20 und Canon LEGRIA HF30
Canon auf der NAB 2018: Canon EOS C100 MKIII vs Vollformat Spiegellose ?
Messevideo: Canon Sumire - erste Canon Vollformat Cine Objektivserie mit PL Mount // NAB 2019
Canon HF100 VS. Canon PowerShot SX530 HS
Unterschied Canon xa 20 und Canon hf g30
24 fps für Canon EOS RP und Canon EOS 90 D als freies Firmware-Download verfügbar
Canon 100-400 an C300 (war: Canon C300 PL auf EF umbauen?)
Neue Canon Objektive: RF 15-35mm F2.8L IS USM, RF 24-70mm F2.8L IS USM und besserer Augen-AF für Canon EOS R und RP
Canon HG 20
Canon HV 20
Canon XL 1
Canon Powershot G2
Canon S2 IS Erfahrungen
Canon MVX250i
Canon EOS R5
Canon 6D für TV?
Canon Ixus 40
Canon EOS 5D 2
Canon HV 30 Datenübertragung
Canon EOS R
Canon 80D ?
Canon FD - Blendenproblem
Canon XL2
Canon EOS 5D Mk IV...

















weitere Themen:
Spezialthemen


16:9
ARD
AVCHD
AVI
Adobe After Effects
Adobe Premiere Pro
After effects
Apple Final Cut Pro
Audio
Avid
Cam
Camcorder
Camera
Canon
Capture
Capturing
Clip
EOS
Editing
Effect
Error
Export
File
Files
Film
Final Cut
Format
Formate
HDR
Import
JVC
Layer
Light
MAGIX video deLuxe
Magix
Microphone
Monitor
Movie
PC
Panasonic
Pinnacle
Pinnacle Studio
Player
Premiere
RAM
RED
Recording
Red
Software
Sony
Sound
Studio
TV
Tape
Video
Videos