Logo Logo
/// 
Qualitätsvergleich mpeg2/xVid - Bitte um Mithilfe

Quality comparison mpeg2/xVid - Please help



Frage von seronil43:
Juni 2009

Hi All,
yes there are some opinions of you in my original thread in the direction of "let the mpeg2 capture, compress twice before you" went, I still have time to experiment, but I still try to not give up so much space on the DVD

In these 2 versions came about:

The first version would be a Halfpal capture, so you could bring at least 2 average movies on a DVD:
http://www.mikroh.de/gp/vhsTheoM2Mi.OrginalCapture.mpg
(; Neck approx 20MB)


The second version is my previous best XVid version of the Fullpal-mpeg2 capture is caused
http://www.mikroh.de/gp/vhsTheoM2Hi.fullpal.crop.deinter_shiftodd.avi
(; same section, at about 7MB)


As much as I try, I can not say which of the two versions look better, or is for me the better, I find quite similar.

Maybe you can your expert with the keen eye out and throw the same time make an assessment? That would be great, then I could easily make up my mind, I next direction in which to experiment.

Thank & Regards
Sero



Antwort von tommyb:

You will not notice any particular jump in quality, because your source does seem to be a VHS and has a resolution anyway.

Even if one were runterskalieren the video to 512x384, you would recognize s.normalen Television with normal seat pitch no difference. You can see that even in apparently MPEG2 version, for which is only 480x576 pixels.

However, if you codierst interlaced sources to XviD, you should use in each case a deinterlacer - especially as the image content anyway movie is (; ergo progressive).




Antworten zu ähnlichen Fragen:
MSU Video Quality Measurement Tool
Help need with Software Engineer roles based in Dublin - C++, DVB, MPEG2
Help - Color Grading reagiert nicht - Resolve 16
Help! LUMIX S5, Ninja V and RIBBON HDMI cable...
media Encoder Timecode geht nicht, need help
F: DVB 2 DVD mit DVD-Patcher 1.06 (help me)
Nero 7 updat und Help
avi (xvid) -> mpeg2 (dvd)
Suche XviD-Codec
Informationen zu den Einstellungen des XVid-Codecs
Frage: DVD auf XVID komprimieren, Seitenverhältnis past nicht (nie)
XviD im Player abspielen
Gibts "nen portablen DVD-Player mit Divx, Xvid?
XViD vs. SVCD
Hinweis benötigt: W ie Xvid-avi mit AC3 in DVD überführen?
XviD, wie multiplexen?
Software für VOB -> DivX/XviD
Z.Zt. DVD-Player mit DivX, XviD im Angebot?
MPV/MP2 nach XviD-AVI?
DVD-Rekorder mit DivX/XviD-Abspielmöglichkeit: Dzt. noch zuviel verlangt?
Windows Media Player spielt Xvid-Avi nicht richtig ab
XVID Video auf bootable live Linux CD?
DivX-Kompatible dateien mit XviD-Encoder erzeugen?
XVID und zerwürfeltes Bild
Linux: Xvid-Datei von DVB-S-Aufnahme schnell erstellen

















weitere Themen:
Spezialthemen


AI
ARD
AVCHD
AVI
Adobe After Effects
Adobe Premiere Pro
After effects
Apple Final Cut Pro
Audio
Avi
Avid
Avid Media Composer
Cam
Camcorder
Camera
Canon
Capture
Capturing
Editing
Effect
Error
Film
Final Cut
Format
HDR
Import
JVC
Layer
Light
MAGIX video deLuxe
Magix
Microphone
Movie
Panasonic
Pinnacle
Pinnacle Studio
Premiere
RAM
RED
Recording
Software
Sony
Sound
Studio
TV
Video
Videos