Logo Logo
/// 
Sony Vegas vs. Premiere CS4

Sony Vegas vs. Premiere CS4



Frage von nachtspion:
April 2009

I have, until recently a test version of Sony Vegas that are very well with AVCHD files could. Now I stand before me the Pro version to get. Looking at the price I thought but that is because I like the Adobe Production Suite can buy at the moment because I'm entitled Education Software (770.92 euros gross) for commercial use to buy.

Unfortunately succeed the AVCHD editing in the trial version of Premiere CS4 does not and I could not try it yourself. Has anyone experience with both cut programs and can order something to say HD editing?

Sony Vegas, there was really great.



Antwort von deti:

AVCHD should already work with CS4. Just the MTS files from the Camera Import. Comparison to Premiere Vegas is slow but slow. Therefore I would suggest you to stay in Vegas. To price: Vegas Pro costs around 380 ¬ - 300 ¬ or without DVD Architect. Vegas Platinum only about 65 ¬.

Deti



Antwort von Marco:

And when the path crosses Movie Studio -> Vegas Pro upgrade is gone, then it comes to 42.00 ¬ for Movie Studio for 390.00 ¬ plus the Vegas Pro Upgrade (at SCS).

That you are at 432.00 euros for the full version of Vegas Pro 8 with DVD Architect Pro 5

Marco








Antwort von Jörg:

Quote:
Comparison to Premiere Vegas is slow but slow.


I can not confirm, of course, depends on the Rechnerconfig from ...

And the price discussion is actually superfluous, at 770, - for the Adobe suite.



Antwort von deti:

Hm .. maybe I'm the only human being synonymous, the Final Cut Pro CS4 and MC3.5 constantly has his nose and still find Vegas a better ;-)

Deti



Antwort von Jörg:

Quote:
Vegas and still finds better ;-)


this is a very different pair of shoes ....



Antwort von Jake the rake:

I would be interested in why you
Quote:
currently entitled [are] Education Software (770.92 euros gross) for commercial use to buy.


?



Antwort von nachtspion:

"Jake The Rake" wrote:
I would be interested in why you
Quote:
currently entitled [are] Education Software (770.92 euros gross) for commercial use to buy.


?


Because I state school pupils s.einer am:
http://www.cobra-shop.de/studenten/pages/shop.jsf?ca=110



Antwort von deti:

"Joerg" wrote:
Quote:
Vegas and still finds better ;-)


this is a very different pair of shoes ....

The intention of this statement I do not understand: Even if the Edu-price for CS4, specifically the stuff is totally oversized. Most of the functions and uses no human being just because every semi-professional CS4 picks, this alone is no guarantee of good results. I understand this senseless spending really not!

... and if already working professionally, then with Avid Media Composer 3.5 - the cost in the package just Edu



Antwort von Jake the rake:

The question referred to the "commercial exploitation". This is normally prohibited EDU versions ...


Or?



Antwort von deti:

The commercial use will depend on the package s.and precisely this cost with the other shop less than 100 ¬. But no preference ...

Deti



Antwort von 02VideoFaBI:

Commercial use is allowed. COMPLETELY SAFE!
All the adobe-Education Products like normal software may be used, they must not only to commercial systems (corporate PCs, ...) installed. Only former Macromedia products may not be commercially used. Stands at Adobe.








Antwort von Jake the rake:

Well, once you have created your product is selling the calculator on which it arose but a "corporate Calculator". If synonymous only a "one-man company" ...

Ultimately, it is difficult or impossible to control ....



Antwort von 02VideoFaBI:

"Jake The Rake" wrote:
Well, once you have created your product is selling the calculator on which it arose but a "corporate Calculator". If synonymous only a "one-man company" ...

Ultimately, it is difficult or impossible to control ....

No.. You can enable projects, which are used commercially. Surely. One must, however, not in a registered establishment or on a PC / Mac, which is sold, installed.



Antwort von nachtspion:

There are 2 versions. The student version and the Education version.

The student version may only be used for private purposes are synonymous Edu Commercial!



Antwort von Shiranai:

"deti" wrote:
Comparison to Premiere Vegas is slow but slow.

I got here and Premiere CS4 s.laufen Vegas recently tested. I think Vegas is not really better. The videos run just as smoothly in Premiere synonymous (perhaps minimally better). Habs after 1 hr test runtergeworfen again because I am the interface cumbersome and cluttered and it can not even managed to have a video in H.264 rauszurendern again.

"night spion" wrote:
(770.92 euros gross)

Why hast thou the amount? Ich hab in Geizhals.s.die Edu CS4 Production Premium for 300 euros gesehn setback. And here and an excerpt from the FAQ of Adobe:

What restrictions exist in the application of Education versions of the products?
Qualified end-users of all products can only acquire a copy. Student Edition products are only for use on home computers and can not be thought on institutional or commercial computers installed
or used.
Former Macromedia Educational Products (Studio 8, Dreamweaver, Flash, etc.) are available only for teaching and administrative purposes and may not be used for commercial purposes.


So I think "commercial computer" is fairly free interpretations. That means at least not that I have on my home computer does not render commercial movies may be, is not it?



Antwort von nachtspion:

"Shiranai" wrote:
So I think "commercial computer" is fairly free interpretations. That means at least not that I have on my home computer does not render commercial movies may be, is not it?


You are right, so clearly this is not written. Above all, what is a commercial computer ...
Perhaps könte you interpret it so that one of his projects Freelancer PC s.Familien handled this on a non-commercial PC makes.

But I think times have read somewhere that you program the student may not make commercial use, so no money can earn. I think it is but just not.



Antwort von yoginaut:

Hello,
the discussion which editing program would be better in my eyes is now in most cases unnecessary. The crucial question is rather: What is the surface cutter s.Besten to justify and to the desired result? (When he already can choose which program it should be).
That should rather take into account, because the programs are approaching with the functions become more and more.
So if you are so far good with Vegas experience you have and thus would be the familiar question whether the remaining programs of the Adobe suite for you to switch it interesting.
Wishes to you but in any case much fun cutting (no preference which system because it is :-)

yoginaut



Antwort von nachtspion:

"yoginaut" wrote:
Hello,
the discussion which editing program would be better in my eyes is now in most cases unnecessary.
yoginaut


You must remember that it is in my case revolves around AVCHD editing. Since some programs appear in problems. From all that I was able to test the intersection with Sony Vegas s.besten possible. I would in no case have anything to convert it to be cut. My quad is strong enough, which has at least taught me Vegas.

Unfortunately, allowing the trial of Premiere CS4 no AVCHD editing, which I could not test synonymous as the liquid runs.

What speaks for Adobe, is the fact that in the Production Suite synonymous nor Photoshop and After Effects is. Illustrator I can synonymous s.and s.brauchen. But if I cut AVCHD can not fluently, brings me synonymous nix.




Antworten zu ähnlichen Fragen:
Sony Vegas in the UK Buy
"Data exchange" with Sony Vegas
Update: Sony Vegas Pro 10.0b
sony vegas pro
Sony Vegas 10 - bugs?
Sony Vegas notify the head for ever?
Sony Vegas Pro 9 with new features
Sony Vegas Pro 9.0 problem
Sony Vegas 9.0 in white?
Sony Vegas sparks?
Sony Professional and extended warranty bundlet Vegas 9
Sony Vegas Pro 9 freezes (s.140KB project file size)
Adobe Premiere CS4 - DV Bänder haben Schwarze Balken
Premiere CS4: Bearbeitung von 4 seperaten Audiospuren - unmöglich?
Windows Premiere CS4 Crash nach Import von AVCHD files
Workflow Überblendung in Premiere nach Wechsel von Vegas
Sony Vegas 13 Abstürze
sony vegas 12 oder 13
Verpixeln in Sony Vegas
verarscht mich Sony Vegas 10?
Sony Vegas - Frameserver Probleme
Cubase 7 vs. Sony Vegas Pro 13
AAF export in Sony Vegas Pro 13
AAF export in Sony Vegas Pro 13
Sony Vegas ruckelt in der Vorschau
Sony Vegas Pro 11 auf Mac

















weitere Themen:
Spezialthemen


16:9
ARD
AVCHD
AVI
Adobe After Effects
Adobe Premiere Pro
After effects
Apple Final Cut Pro
Audio
Avid
Avid Media Composer
Cam
Camcorder
Camera
Canon
Capture
Capturing
Clip
EOS
Editing
Effect
Error
Export
File
Files
Film
Final Cut
Format
Formate
HDR
Import
JVC
Layer
Light
MAGIX video deLuxe
Magix
Microphone
Monitor
Movie
PC
Panasonic
Pinnacle
Pinnacle Studio
Player
Premiere
RAM
RED
Recording
Red
Software
Sony
Sound
Studio
TV
Tape
Video
Videos