Logo Logo
directory schraeg
Camcorders· Cinema-Kamera· Computers· Drohnen· GPU· Kamera-Zubehör· Video-DSLR· accessories
Compositing· Color correction· DV Editing

Shooting· Sound
Forschung· Reviews· Streaming
/// News
When formats die: Because of Flash many Orginal 9/11 are no longer displayable

When formats die: Because of Flash many Orginal 9/11 are no longer displayable

[19:14 sat,11.September 2021   by ]    

Today marks the 20th anniversary of the spectacular terrorist attack on the World Trade Center - but those who want to view the coverage including interactive features and videos from that time online often encounter a very special problem: Flash (formerly Macromedia CHECK, later Adobe), which was widely used at the time, has been no longer supported since Adobe ended support last year, i.e. content presented in Flash can no longer be viewed directly.

Interactive Flash graphic about 9/11 on ABC News

Large media experimented just in their 9/11 reporting with dynamic or interactive contents, texts including diagrams and video, which were then programmed in Flash, as for example beside CNN also the Washington Post or ABC News. Of course, this problem also affects many other network contents from that time, which are now no longer accessible.

Some editorial offices have replaced at least some of the no longer accessible and particularly valuable content as documents of contemporary history with some effort by simple web pages including videos or HTML5 animations, such as USA Today, others such as the New York Times or the Internet Archive use the open source Flash Player Emulation Ruffle in the form of a browser extension for Chrome and Safari or a web app to replay old Flash content, but this is not always 100% successful.

Interactive Flash graphic about 9/11 on ABC News

via Ruffle

Even Adobe itself recommends uninstalling any remaining Flash players due to their security vulnerabilities. For its part, an Adobe spokesperson said in a statement, "Adobe has discontinued support for Flash Player as of December 31, 2020. Unfortunately, these older web pages can no longer be played because the loading of the Flash plugin is blocked in the browser. Like all Americans, we lived through the horrific events of 9/11 and understand the important role Flash played in helping media organizations portray and tell the stories of that tragic day."

Adobe EOL for Flash Player.

Flash, which was legendarily buggy, often memory- or power-hungry, and full of security holes, has been replaced by the increasingly powerful (and open!) version 5 of HTML, which through its universal native browser support (at least of the most important features) across operating system boundaries since 2014 are a perfect "player" for all sorts of media and work natively. However, support for especially new formats by the various browser manufacturers sometimes differs here as well.

The problem with old media and formats - even digital

This highlights a general problem with proprietary standards in particular: if they are discontinued by the manufacturer and no new versions of the respective player are developed for new platforms, then content created in them ends up in the digital graveyard.

Obsolete media (Photo by Jason Curtis)

We are used to the end of mechanical old media, such as VHS or Betamax video, 3 1/2 or 5 1/4 inch floppy disks, audio cassettes, various data tape formats (such as the Commodore Datasette), laserdiscs, various film formats - if you want to archive these old media and preserve them for posterity, you not only have to worry about the physical condition of the respective media (how fast does which material age? How can the aging be stopped, which can normally always mean a loss of data or even illegibility?), but also about keeping playback devices for the respective formats ready and in good condition. The Berlin Arsenal, for example, keeps numerous viewing and editing devices for films for its extensive film archive, because the digitization of cinemas means that there are fewer and fewer film projectors.

Surprisingly, digital media also suffer from these problems - archiving them is easier because they only need to be stored on a digital storage device for access, but if there is no player for the respective media format that can interpret and display the data correctly (such as graphics, videos or interactive animations), then they are also dead. Especially the once ubiquitous distribution of Flash and its special role as a universal, cross-operating system and cross-browser platform, be it for interactive content on the web, animated web page menus, animations, videos up to games and utilities, makes its end especially painful.

Obsolete Media (Photo by Jason Curtis)

In the worst case also hardware can be no more or only limited usable, because for the setup or the operation necessary or useful programs were programmed in Flash - so happened for example with old HP printers. Often, interactive CDs were also programmed in Flash, whose included Flash players refuse to install on an operating system unknown to them (from then future OS versions of Windows) and thus cannot be played.

VLC player support formats.

Open standards provide accessibility

All this speaks for the use of open rather than proprietary formats and such possible backward compatibility through new formats and players. For example, the popular open source VLC player supports a myriad of old (now defunct) video formats, such as MPEG-1/2, DivX, Xvid, DV, Cinepak, WMV, Sorenson or Real Video, which thus remain playable. Likewise, new browsers can always display ancient HTML pages - a prerequisite for old net content to remain accessible and not end up as cryptic data garbage.

Link more infos at bei edition.cnn.com

deutsche Version dieser Seite: 20 Jahre 9/11 - wegen eingestelltem Flash fehlen viele Bilder


  Vorige News lesen Nächste News lesen 
bildSamsung: Neue Pro Plus und Evo Plus microSD/SD-Karten mit bis zu 160 MB/s bildKostenlose Filme auf VHS oder DVD für Alle? FreeBlockbuster.org

related news:1E0Lexar Diamond CFexpress Type B: The World's Fastest CFexpress Memory Card 20.June 2022
Problems with NAND Flash production: SSD prices will increase by 5-10% 12.February 2022
Video stabilizer ReelSteady 2.0 coming to GoPro Player in 2022 29.October 2021
Western Digital changes NAND Flash of WD Blue SN550 SSD 28.August 2021
Enlightening Golem interview on 20 years of VLC player 6.March 2021
AJA Ki Pro Ultra 12GAJA Ki Pro Ultra 12G: 12G 4K-UltraHD ProRes multi-channel recorder and player 1.June 2020
New Cine-optics player: IRIX 150mm T 3.0 macro 1:1 lens to come 19.July 2019
alle Newsmeldungen zum Thema Player
1E0Panasonic GH6 Firmware 2.0 bringt 120 fps ProRes RAW mit Ninja V+ und internes DCI 4K ProRes 5.July 2022
Tilta: Camera Cage for Canon EOS R5C incl. battery solution for 8K 50/60p RAW 27.June 2022
Asus ROG Swift OLED PG48UQ: Large 4K OLED monitor with 138 Hz and 98% DCI-P3 21.June 2022
New firmware versions for Sony A1 and A7SIII - including 8K 4:2:2 10-bit recording 14.June 2022
Teradek Serv Micro: wireless camera monitoring via HDMI on local network and Internet 13.June 2022
Samsung Odyssey Neo G8 with mini-LED technology and 2,000 nits brightness: First 240Hz 4K gaming mon 12.June 2022
Panasonic LUMIX GH6 firmware 2.0: internal recording of C4K/FullHD ProRes as well as 4K at 120 fps w 8.June 2022
alle Newsmeldungen zum Thema Formats

[nach oben]

Archiv Newsmeldungen


July - June - May - April - March - February - January

December - November - October - September - August - July - June - May - April - March - February - January






















deutsche Version dieser Seite: 20 Jahre 9/11 - wegen eingestelltem Flash fehlen viele Bilder

last update : 5.Juli 2022 - 18:02 - slashCAM is a project by channelunit GmbH- mail : slashcam@--antispam:7465--slashcam.de - deutsche Version