Logo Logo
/// 
HDV: JVC, Canon oder Sony ?

HDV: JVC, Canon or Sony?



Frage von The Magpie:
Juli 2007

Hello,

for image, fashion and Making-Of-productions, documentaries and small we are in search of a HDV camera, designed as the successor of our SonyVX the 2100th

Envisaged, we have the Canon XH A1, SonyHVR-Z1 and the JVC GY HD 110th
I would be delighted if someone's eventual experience reports or neutral
Buy recommendations and price gives us the buying decision so easily.

Our tendency is currently used to JVC because they shoulder as an additional camera is capable of and
with Exchangable optics and their options a "professional" basis.

Read, however, we have increased that users that included Lens,
criticize. Nor would we, as with all "professional" cameras, the Auto Focus function,
or a button for quick auto-focus in manual mode is missing because our
Productions, often of many and fast movements (eg Catwalk) are marked. If this concentration
on an absolute manual focus simply a habit and or can Lernsache
this is a serious problem to be overburdened.

Finally, a very general question:
We are looking therefore for HDV to access the latest technology and to be
in the coming years not to have to retrofit. Is this a sensible idea
HDV currently synonymous if maybe not so much in demand? Big issue is definitely
16:9 and the better image quality ...

Thanks for any hints and recommendations ...



Antwort von Macmacmac:

So I would take the Canon (ups I've already mentioned). Stand back then, more or less facing the same decision.
The Sony offers the same as the Canon, it is only about 1500 ¬ more expensive and this extra cost is clearly not worth it.
The JVC has unfortunately not so good reviews received on the one hand due to the inferior Optics and secondly because of the bad Progressivleistung probably not really great look.
Würd synonymous So I still take the A1, like synonymous twice instead of a JVC.



Antwort von Anne_trister:

the manual focus in the HDV range, even with
focus aid is not as trivial as sd.
if you are not just a still life with a recording or
preview monitor will be working in the regular course with
the henkelcams (a1/z1/fx1/fx7/h1) in the AF mode to work.
(except in lowlight AF here because of the ever
loses focus). as in a hd schultercam with the
manual is focusieren was not yet expressed ...
and I would be interested in talk shows at least ....
saw you last time, often times fokussierprobleme.
gruß cj








Antwort von Axel:

There is no autofocus I imagine also problematic before. When HDV is the manual focusing without any electronic assistance (or an external monitor, but that we leave for foreign reportage times before) is not possible. The JVC is probably because the S / W Viewfinder, sharpness as red contour shows. This allows a yes on the safe Page, but it certainly requires time, still other aspects to concentrate.

At Ease jerky of the Progressive, I think not. That it was synonymous of the Panasonic DVX 100 and of the Canon A1, incidentally, synonymous of experienced testers. As it turned out, there were two reasons: First, the NLE needed an attitude - as synonymous with computer means, for the only HDV Progressive "no Halbbildpräferenz" (but still half). Secondly, there is a slight Bildstottern too fast pans in the nature of the half-motion information. It differs not 720p of analog film.

EDIT: If I am not mistaken, the JVC synonymous "50p", so it should be no more bucking. Question just how in the finishing order correctly handled.



Antwort von Anne_trister:

"Axel" wrote:
There is no autofocus I imagine also problematic before. When HDV is the manual focusing without any electronic assistance (or an external monitor, but that we leave for foreign reportage times before) is not possible. The JVC is probably because the S / W Viewfinder, sharpness as red contour shows. This allows a yes on the safe Page, but it certainly requires time, still other aspects to concentrate.


after my experiences with the FX7 is the focus in the sw / mode
(picture profile on sw / expandmodus Type2) are not sufficient. only
contour can increase at the high resolution makes sense to use
But in some situations and not synonymous as one of the fast
moving subjects (sports) regulate the manual is time a
ask s.die hd group.
gruß cj



Antwort von Anne_trister:

"Axel" wrote:

At Ease jerky of the Progressive, I think not. That it was synonymous of the Panasonic DVX 100 and of the Canon A1, incidentally, synonymous of experienced testers. As it turned out, there were two reasons: First, the NLE needed an attitude - as synonymous with computer means, for the only HDV Progressive "no Halbbildpräferenz" (but still half). Secondly, there is a slight Bildstottern too fast pans in the nature of the half-motion information. It differs not 720p of analog film.


There is, of course, which was tested as bad, the test comes from the digital video asset. Must every man for himself to decide how far he believes what it is.




Antworten zu ähnlichen Fragen:
JVC GZ MS210 or Canon Vixia FS306
CANON XL-H1 JVC GY HD 200 VS
Canon FS200 and JVC GZ-MS120
Canon HV 20/30 vs. JVC GZ-HD7E
PanaGS60/80 or Canon MD130 or JVC GRD 725?
Which camcorder ....... Canon, Jvc ...?
Canon Optics for JVC HD110E?
Buy Canon or JVC
JVC GR370 or Canon MV850i??
Transmission problems with the Sony HDV 1000 e
New HDV shoulder camcorder of Sony: HVR-HD1000U
Sony reveals new Professional HDV professional camcorder
SONY HVR S270E HDV
Sony HDR-HC7E: HD/HDV auf PC kopieren
Vergleich Canon / JVC Camcorder
Vergleich JVC und Sony -Henkelmänner
JVC GF-S1000HE über Sony GV-D200E zum PC
Erster Eindruck: Sony HXR-NX100 gegen JVC GY-HM 650
Sony-Stativ Sony VCT-80AV mit CANON Legria GX10 verbinden
NTSC HDV
Welche HDV-Kamera?
Videoschnitt - Monitor für HDV
HDV und Schnitt, Formatumwandlung
HDV-Camcorder mit Cassetten?
White Clip bei HDV
bessserer stativkopf als 701 HDV ?

















weitere Themen:
Spezialthemen


16:9
AI
ARD
AVCHD
AVI
Adobe After Effects
Adobe Premiere Pro
After effects
Apple Final Cut Pro
Audio
Avid
Avid Media Composer
Cam
Camcorder
Camera
Canon
Capture
Capturing
Clip
EOS
Editing
Effect
Error
Export
File
Files
Film
Final Cut
Format
Formate
HDR
Import
JVC
KI
Layer
Light
MAGIX video deLuxe
Magix
Microphone
Monitor
Movie
PC
Panasonic
Pinnacle
Pinnacle Studio
Player
Premiere
RAM
RED
Recording
Red
Software
Sony
Sound
Studio
TV
Tape
Video
Videos