Logo

/// 
Edius Broadcast vs. Final Cut Pro

Edius Broadcast vs.. Final Cut Pro



Frage von der Schneider:
Juli 2008

Dear People,

as a newcomer here in the forum, I would like a certain popular times to ask to get rid of assessment:

I want a new section to purchase space and wrote a budget of around 8000 ¬.

There is great emphasis on P2 material to be rotated but of course synonymous dv.

I cut for years with Edius 2.5 and have the Edius workflow own love.
previous reports speak for Edius in the broadcast version of Good kompatiilität hd with many sources, good real-time capability and own the Canopus HD codec.

Final Cut Pro has been clearly the better known of what happens in the customer acquisition play a role and it seems that "professional" to be.

comparative wär to make between a:

Mac Pro 8-Core 3.2 Ghz
8 GB RAM / NVIDIA 8800 GT HD 512MB/500GB
Final Cut Studio 2
Blackmagic DeckLink HD Extreme
new model with HDMI and IO 2K
2 Apple 23 "Cinema HD Display
3 terabytes of additional internal memory
(3 * 1000GB)
about 7600 ¬ (dieAgenten.de)

and a PC:
8x Xeon 3.00 GHz
12GBDDR II RAM, Quadro channel with 4x 800MHz
512MB Quadro QFX3700
ProTools LE 7.4
250GB SATA II-300
4TB RAID 10
Edius SP / HDV
8000 ¬ (inside multimedia)

I would be more than estimates, opinions and alternative synonymous thanks in advance.



Antwort von weitwinkel:

I work very pleased with Edius pro (not broadcast) but would
in your case to hire to Final Cut Pro, tend, as a mac book pro thee synonymous
p2 on the persuasive prima processed ... I trust in Edius
variant of the laptop is not so much.
gruß cj



Antwort von PowerMac:

Final Cut is an industry standard!





Antwort von der Schneider:

I am aware of the Final Cut Pro is a art industry standard is.
I feel for the overall workflow and the performance under the aspect of cost.
I suspect that I am part of the money for Final Cut Pro to simply pay that Final Cut Pro.

I have the experience that Edius has great features to me as a good cutter and help think that the broadcast version schnitprogramm as Final Cut Pro as well.
but I do not know.

I also know I am with apple just does not look and it seems that the systems are not so easily be upgraded.

maybe there are still a few thoughts on the subject ...



Antwort von PowerMac:

Edius is equally good? There are various tests and comparisons between Edius and Final Cut Pro, which should convince you.



Antwort von der Schneider:

@ Powermac
Could you link to so-NEN nem test indicate? That would be very enlightening ..



Antwort von Bernd E.:

"Schneider" wrote:
... I suspect that I am part of the money for Final Cut Pro to simply pay that Final Cut Pro is ...

To a certain extent this may be - as with many other brands synonymous - even vote, but the reason for the probably around 400 euros extra cost compared to Edius, I see more is that you with an entire FCS program package including Soundtrack, Motion, Color, etc. get . Edius, I know too little to even be able to compare, but look at s.besten times at exactly what you are in FCS and get Edius. From the price-performance ratio is currently first in my opinion unbeatable.

Gruß Bernd E.




Antworten zu ähnlichen Fragen:
Final Cut Pro 7 - External Tone asynchronous to the image
Final Cut Pro 7 to Final Cur Pro X
Question for Final Cut Pro update 5:04
Transitions in Final Cut Pro - always "poor content"
Rumors around Apple's next explosion Final Cut Pro
Different FPS in Final Cut Pro
Next Final Cut Pro version presented to selected audiences
Lamination of Fussler on Lens in Final Cut Pro
Final Cut Pro 7 will not install
Own transition (; Transition) create in Motion, used in Final Cut Pro?
Final Cut Pro "loses" media -> Connect new?
Proper export from Final Cut Pro 7.0
Final Cut Pro X und Colorsync besser als Broadcast Video Output?
Final Cut Pro X 10.0.3 Update mit MultiCam, Broadcast-Monitoring, PSD-Ebene
Apple Final Cut Pro X 10.0.4 Update mit Broadcast Monitoring und mehr Stabi
Final Cut Pro X vrs Edius 7 - Part 1-2
Final Cut 6 to Edius
Where is the easier to use: with or Edius Final Cut 6?
SDI Broadcast Signal zu Stream!!
Unterschied Kino vs. Broadcast
Workflow für Videofils aus der EOS7D für Broadcast
AVC-Intra 100Mbit 422 10 bit als Broadcast deliverable???
Panasonic HC-X929-Live Broadcast
FFMBC-FFmpeg for Broadcast and professionals?
Breaker-Taste an Broadcast-Kameras
Arri Alexa: ProRes Optionen und Broadcast































weitere Themen:
Spezialthemen


16:9
AVCHD
AVI
Adobe After Effects
Adobe Premiere Pro
After effects
Apple Final Cut Pro
Audio
Avid
Cam
Camcorder
Camera
Canon
Capture
Capturing
Clip
EOS
Editing
Effect
Error
Export
File
Files
Film
Final Cut
Format
Formate
HDR
Import
JVC
Layer
Light
MAGIX video deLuxe
Microphone
Monitor
Movie
PC
Panasonic
Pinnacle
Player
Premiere
RAM
RED
Recording
Red
Software
Sony
Sound
Studio
TV
Tape
Video
Videos



update am 27.November 2014 - 18:00
ist ein Projekt der channelunit GmbH
*Datenschutzhinweis*