Logo Logo
/// 
Adobe Premiere oder Final Cut

Adobe Premiere or Final Cut



Frage von Nio:
April 2006

Hello,

I would just interresieren aml what would make her, in front of you whom are two computers with the same power. On a Mac is, on the other Windows. You have a Final Cut Pro and the other Adobe Premiere Pro 2
You can take a free. What would it take?



Antwort von Gast:

Well, Final Cut. Then I could love a Mac and I nen Untitled Document karsou buy new PC.



Antwort von Nio:

Hi,

Have you ever used Mac nen? Since thou canst Ctrl + ALT + DEL password, since it takes a long time until you croaked a program





Antwort von Axel:

Search, and you will find the Battle of Gondor, replayed in slashcamforum.
No doubt even Steve Jobs has just scored a coup.
Let's see on that.
For our purposes, there is of Apple has a Production Suite, which provides for a reasonable price of about ¬ 1200 a high-end solution of all the software we need (Photoshop, nor should) do so. The equivalent of Adobe Production Studio, although only costs 2000 ¬ and scores with the inclusive Photoshop and After Effects, but the other applications lose in Comparison with the Apple products, especially APP with Final Cut Pro and Encore (very much) with DSP.
Even with After Effects, Shake is a competitor has been built up which is likely to prevail.

Nevertheless, one has as expected, on average PC user with lower purchase price. This is primarily for amateurs still the most important argument for Windows. However, if the aforementioned Adobe package some problems running on the Intel Mac, there will be Jobs and Gates shaking hands. One of the Macs sold, and the other Windows and Adobe, a new version of its software.



Antwort von PowerMac:

I do not know any Windows users who find great Windows.
I do not know any Mac users can not find the great Mac OS.

Usually we say that we would need a Mac. Finally, there would be synonymous with Windows on a cheap PC. Right.

But if you had the choice and the "Macs-are-so-expensive" argument falls away, but chooses None Windows.

Premiere Pro 2 is such a thing. I maintain a professional, it is not. Especially since no HD format are integrated. In Final Cut goes against everything. HDV-2K. For features, stability and ease of use many tests have already said something. Both Final Cut Pro as synonymous APP2.

DVD Studio Pro Encore suggests. Motion does not propose After Effects. Except in the case Benutzfreundlichkeit, templates, and real-time performance. Soundtrack Pro: Adobe counterpart, I do not know. Soundtrack is easy and good. Walter Murch is on it. Jarhead, Cold Mountain and were set to be cut with Final Cut Pro.
http://www.apple.com/pro/film/murch/



Antwort von universl:

Final Cut Pro is a highly professional manner, but can not everything. As HVX-720p 50 user falls flat (bad for slow motion). For MacOS you can stand how you will, my OS of choice is now synonymous Linux and Solaris, but there is nothing with film-cutting (with exception of Linux, but do not always work as they should).

My personal opinion about the future of MacOS is:

It is set as the development is too expensive. The Mach kernel is old, the developer of it off of Apple, the errors in the OS are piling up. Windows is already aufm Apple, the applications like Final Cut Pro will then be synonymous soon run on Windows. I do not trust me because almost bet.

From this perspective, and I absolutely bad opinion about jobs and the general Mac users (an elite circle of the Boot Camp should be an absolute horror) I never get a MAC into the house. So, unfortunately, not synonymous Final Cut Pro (which is really excellent).

Addendum:

Gift I will take Final Cut Pro already * g *



Antwort von retiez:

hi UNIVERSL,

Perhaps you can tell me when I ask to help?
wär cool, retiez



Antwort von jens:

"PowerMac" wrote:
I do not know any Windows users who find great Windows.
I do not know any Mac users can not find the great Mac OS.


This is certainly a typical message from 'nem classical
PC vs. MAC Riot
Tend my next synonymous Calculator will be a Mac.

Have fun with another exchange of blows ;-)
Jens




Antwort von Gast:

Actually, it was not my intention, an ideological Windows / Mac to trigger discussion. It should probably go more like Final Cut / Premiere.
But due to the question "You may as a [computer] to take charge.? What would you take" I could only answer that.



Antwort von semifor:

"UNIVERSL" wrote:
Final Cut Pro is a highly professional manner, but can not everything. As HVX-720p 50 user falls flat (bad for slow motion). For MacOS you can stand how you will, my OS of choice is now synonymous Linux and Solaris, but there is nothing with film-cutting (with exception of Linux, but do not always work as they should).

My personal opinion about the future of MacOS is:

It is set as the development is too expensive. The Mach kernel is old, the developer of it off of Apple, the errors in the OS are piling up. Windows is already aufm Apple, the applications like Final Cut Pro will then be synonymous soon run on Windows. I do not trust me because almost bet.

From this perspective, and I absolutely bad opinion about jobs and the general Mac users (an elite circle of the Boot Camp should be an absolute horror) I never get a MAC into the house. So, unfortunately, not synonymous Final Cut Pro (which is really excellent).


Wow, UNIVERSL: with such a post in a Mac forum, you would probably be stoned :-)
But I see that I stand with my opinion, not quite alone, for synonymous, I think long term, the importance of OS X could diminish, rather, what might at some point might even lead to a complete real setting. Nevertheless, with just now, the Mac has become more interesting: I'm looking for is certified by the end of a workstation that of Avid. If the new macs and are not priced to meet these more expensive, I would certainly be considered (to draw comparison with an HP workstation, the macs are in fact cheaper).

However, in order to respond to the input Posting:

FC is in your Comparison certainly the better choice, especially with regard to professional format. It depends but probably synonymous to the Camera and set to the required format, which are important to you. You only take on DV, so is probably every program (on a PC, there are only handle so many other premiere), whereas in the targeted HVX200 will probably cause some cut solutions to problems (at 720 50p at the moment anyway at all actually up) on Edius - I am not so sure.
Ultimately, there is still synonymous in reference to how far you're willing to really learn the program. There's huge differences, and depending on what you have for requirements that would be one or the other solution is better for you.

In your choices, I would certainly prefer to FC, have in the election on 2 PC's to choose between 2 programs, I would always choose Avid - synonymous when it initially because 'ne fairly high learning curve there.

Greeting
January



Antwort von semifor:

Hi, mir gehts da like Jens, synonymous, I have little problems with XP
so stable, no calculator was with me. OK, OK, I had never been synonymous nen mac. The idea of using both platforms for what. With Security absouter FC will come up with the first programs are there.
Curiosity about other NLE has always been great, the experiment with Edius has just become established as a big mistake, because Final Cut promises much more.
Golden times?
Jörg




Antworten zu ähnlichen Fragen:
Hardware suggestion for Premiere, AE, Lightroom
Strips at reducing speeds in Premiere P. Poor quality.
Export Premiere: Volume raise no control Over
Adobe Premiere Pro CS 5.5, it can not update itself.
Premiere Pro shortcut "Show entire sequence"?
PC for Premiere Pro 5
After Effects and Premiere sometime synonymous with ATI support?
Export issues with AE and Premiere Pro
Anchor Point in Premiere Pro
Premiere Pro2: font is not recognized
Alternatives to Premiere Pro
Premiere Pro 1.5 on Windows 7
Final Cut, Davinci oder Premiere?
Mit Final Cut X den Videoschnitt anfangen und mit Premiere beenden?
Probleme mit Adobe Premiere pro CC 2015! (Morph Cut, funkt garnicht. usw.)
Cut with Final Cut Pro X: Second World War Epic Movie 'Unknown Soldier' Breaks Finland Box Office Record.
Final Cut X
Final Cut ruckelt :(
final cut x - Doku :D
Final Cut Pro X 10.3.1
Final cut showreel
Fragen zu Final Cut Pro X
Cinema look, Final Cut pro X
Workflow Final Cut Pro X
Final Cut 7 kann 4K! Oder
Final Cut Layout zurücksetzen

















weitere Themen:
Spezialthemen


16:9
ARD
AVCHD
AVI
Adobe After Effects
Adobe Premiere Pro
After effects
Apple Final Cut Pro
Audio
Avid
Cam
Camcorder
Camera
Canon
Capture
Capturing
Clip
EOS
Editing
Effect
Error
Export
File
Files
Film
Final Cut
Format
Formate
HDR
Import
JVC
Layer
Light
MAGIX video deLuxe
Magix
Microphone
Monitor
Movie
PC
Panasonic
Pinnacle
Pinnacle Studio
Player
Premiere
RAM
RED
Recording
Red
Software
Sony
Sound
Studio
TV
Tape
Video
Videos