Logo Logo
Canon XH-A1 oder Panasonic HVX200

Canon XH-A1 or Panasonic HVX200

Frage von wolfi28041990:
Februar 2010

Hey People,
I ask you a short and concise for your opinions!
And indeed, I need a new cam ne am, on ner film school in Vienna and will be used for both short and feature films.
I have an eye on the Canon XH-A1 thrown, this gives new around 3,700 ¬.
I also can ne used Panasonic HVX200, construction year 2006 with approximately 600 tape hours to get 2,700 ¬.
What would you advise me?

lg wolfi

Antwort von Manuell:


So I will see both Prices too high, because there you get for the price of the XH A1 yes even the HPX171 new!

Taking hold again as the storage medium play a major role, P2 cards to Mini DV tapes.

What does a tape for an hour material? Sun 3-5 Euro? And a 32 GB P2 card as 500, - Euro.

What do you want to make it with the Camera? What does your editing system / calculator / software like?

Antwort von strike300xxx:

I had both cameras.

Handling is better with the HVX200 IMHO, as a professional. Much has arrived where it is synonymous of larger models is accustomed.

The finer and sharper images but also makes the Canon.

Antwort von Mink:


Both models you might want to try and make up your mind then.

The dir "offered" cameras are too expensive. A new XH-A1 would cost around 3000 ¬ and a used (in your case, 4 years old) HVX not much more than 2000 ¬

Antwort von nicecam:

XH-A1 or XH-A1 (s)?

There is new but already a lot cheaper than [not cheap ;-)]

HVX200 times as approximately twice as expensive. Well, professional format, although in the Picture, the XH-A1 impression uppity.

I refer now to the Comparison of

Antwort von nicecam:

Huppsala, 2mal 18.44 clock, 18.52 clock 2 times - then it went to 100ths of seconds, and the opinions are alike before.

;-) Oh, I see grad: And once more, at approximately 18.57, the clock around

Antwort von Jott:

What interested the band hours at an HVX? Surely you are looking for any DV camcorder, right? HD is just as (expensive) P2 cards.

Antwort von Meggs:

"Jott" wrote:
What interested the band hours at an HVX?

Volume hours is the wrong word. The hours of operation'll find it interesting. A tapeless camcorder is not synonymous lasts forever.

Antwort von wolfi28041990:

Thank you for the quick reply!
So I cut up book now (although SD) on nem FUSI laptop - 2-core with 2,5 Ghz, 4Gb Ram and Win 7th But as appreciative I eh ne change will be necessary .. How much strain for the material of the HVX the PC hardware in contrast to HDV?
How much per GB fits on the P2 cards?
And when I get ne XH-A1 produces Cheap? Any recommendations?

My mind is to estimate the life, a 4 years old camera and I still keep a few more euro equivalent (which it n.is) Neugerät war ..


Antwort von Manuell:

On a 16 gig P2Karte fit 16 minutes in 1080 25p or 720 50p, 720 25p, or 32 minutes.

For example DVCUT you get the XH A1 cheaper.

For 3800, - you'll just get the successor to the HVX200 have new, so the HPX171, without the tape drive. Just because you've got then the more expensive storage medium.

The material of the P2 cards is less demanding in terms of hardware than HDV. Since your computer should still be as suitable.

Antwort von PUDU:

Hello Wolf,

I have to sell before my XH-A1 + WD-H72 wide angle adapter and 3 batteries. It is in very good Gebrauchtzustand.
(Not more than 30 head hours)

The camera is about 1.5 years and the adapter 1 years old.

Dignity for all together 2,600 ¬ + shipping call.
Can they, of course, synonymous like for me to visit in Berlin.

Meld dich, if you're interested.

Antworten zu ähnlichen Fragen:
Canon XH-A1 display set properly
Canon XH-A1 24F
Canon XH-A1: Clean Lens
Canon XHA1 with Primier Pro
Search presets for Canon XHA1 ...
Tele Converter for Canon XHA1
A tribute s.die - Canon XH-A1
Canon XH-A1S questions
Canon xh-align s.and xh-A1S
Canon XH-A1 exposure adjustment
iMac instead of Pro Canon XH-A1S
Canon XH-A1 - Auto-adjustment?
Suche Fisheye für Hvx200
Hvx200 Zoom Hebel geht nicht ?
Hvx200 Pufferbatterie?
Panasonic GH6 mit 8K Video und neuem AF-System? - Panasonic bestätigt neues GH Model
Panasonic mit leistungsstärkerer Bilderkennungs-KI: Bald auch in Panasonic Kameras?
Metadata Tool ( Panasonic G series, Nikon, Canon and Fuji) für Resolve
Panasonic-, Nikon-, Canon-, Fuji- und Sony-Metadaten-Import für Resolve
Rolling Shutter Werte von Blackmagic, Canon, Fuji, Nikon, Panasonic, Kinefinity und Sony
Sony, Canon, Panasonic und Nikon locken mit Cashback-Aktionen
AG DOK Kameratest 2020 - u.a. mit Blackmagic 6K, Canon C500 MkII, Panasonic S1(H) und Sony FX9
Vergleich Videostabilisierung: Fujifilm X-T4, Panasonic S1H, Nikon Z6, Canon EOS-1D X Mark III vs GH5
Wer hat die beste Video-Stabilisierung? Sony A7S III vs Canon EOS R5 vs Panasonic S1H
Canon R6 oder Panasonic S5? Pro/Contra
Der Dynamikumfang von Canon EOS R5 / R6, Panasonic S5 und Sony A7SIII im Vergleich

weitere Themen:

Adobe After Effects
Adobe Premiere Pro
After effects
Apple Final Cut Pro
Avid Media Composer
Final Cut
MAGIX video deLuxe
Pinnacle Studio