Logo Logo
/// 
Final Cut gegen Edius 6

Final Cut 6 to Edius



Frage von gunman:
März 2011

Hi,

I found on the following Edius Forum Comparison:


I would be interested to know what you think?



Antwort von Axel:

Indisputable and therefore probably synonymous is undeniable is that Final Cut Pro still only runs on 32bit and lose for this reason alone against Edius. As the moderator says s.Schluss: There may be some things after all speaks for Final Cut Pro. The charge is a very good workflow tutorial, how to Final Cut Pro does not:

1. Not to import H.264 clips, click on the Log and Transfer. One sets on each clip in - and Outpunkte (if you will), it shall designate and click on "Submit", then one turns to the next. While sight the next, the first is converted to one of the ProRes format. If we use for the transmission, the EOS-plugin (which you need anyway, unless you want the clips will before import with MpegStreamclip or Compressor walk), you get even a running clock time time code, while the original Movs otherwise always at 00: 00:00:00 would begin.

With the standard ProRes422 you have at least the same real time as in Edius, but if you bet on LT or AIC (still high-1a), there is sometimes much more. This aspect concerns the traditional intermediate function that offered synonymous before the real-time support with Edius Canopus. ProRes for talks later in the workflow even more.

2. With the lack of experience of the author with Final Cut Pro can assume that he real-time settings (there are 'retained Frame Rate "Unlimited real time" when selecting the priority or "best image quality," as well as a dynamic combination of both) is not exhausted added. As always synonymous: It is almost never useful to render something and it is never necessary.

The "warning of dropped frames," in which playback is interrupted, is a further indication of the inexperience of the author. This omission is only the live and playback is generally only relevant for a Edit to tape "(it is contrary to the real-time options" dynamic "and" image quality ", which are omitted in doubt, frames). And the cut on tape is not yes to agree with the cutting of EOS Utility. One would have disabled the warning in the preferences, and the playback would be undisturbed. How about with the Edius preview? Is there no compromise in image quality even in the frame rate? Then that would indeed be a true high-performance feature.

3. Instead of the "Layout Editor" of Edius could have been scaled by private treaty in Final Cut Pro is the Picture in the canvas to make the PiP, the route over the motion settings would not have been necessary. Did the author is not comfortable.

4. Section is only the first step. In Edius begins after importing the tables and qualify the clips, what happened with Final Cut Pro already. Many want to or process the material must still next, keyword effects, compositing, color correction. That renders it not in H.264, which was indeed only the circumstances, accepted as a recording codec and otherwise rather than heavily compressed codec issue is concerned. They mastered for quality reasons in a better codec. Now I know Canopus, but probably would be very okay. I'm just wondering: What advantage did the whole native Chose, but if s.Ende what else is? And how then are the tools in Edius to perform the edits oe? What results, what achieves the functionality and the quality of Motion and Color?

On the whole, and the surface of Edius is very functional and inviting. I actually wish this speed for Final Cut Pro.



Antwort von gunman:

Thanks Axel, this is already a qualified answer to my opinion without controversy great!





Antwort von gunman:

Hi Axel,

Indisputable and therefore probably synonymous is undeniable is that Final Cut Pro still only runs on 32bit and for any reason to lose Edius already.


Edius is synonymous bit on 32: only for info!



Antwort von Axel:

"Gunman" wrote:
Hi Axel,

Indisputable and therefore probably synonymous is undeniable is that Final Cut Pro still only runs on 32bit and for any reason to lose Edius already.


Edius is synonymous bit on 32: only for info!


Then you have an outdated version.
Quote:
The most important new features of EDIUS 5.5 in brief:
- Support now synonymous (32 are also 64bit and 64bit drivers for EDIUS NX and EDIUS SP and the new cards with the delivery!) For Windows 7


But there are already Edius 6th Quote of here . If you argumentierst course with "Storm" or other hardware would no longer comparable Prices.



Antwort von heinzbCH:

Edius 6 is also "only" a 32-bit application, but runs on a 64 bit OS as 32 bit application



Antwort von Ian:

I have adjusted the test with Premiere CS5 Windows 7 64bit ultimate. Even with hardware acceleration is turned off the preview round.



Antwort von Axel:

"Ian" wrote:
I have adjusted the test with Premiere CS5 Windows 7 64bit ultimate. Even with hardware acceleration is turned off the preview round.


CS5? What war'n it? Matrox Mini? If the synonymous, originally for Avid MC5 (Edu) purchased. True, it is synonymous Sun However, it is clearly yes 64bit.



Antwort von gunman:

Axel, you're wrong: Eidus runs on Windows 7 64 bit but only on 32 bit!

Errare humanum est!



Antwort von gunman:

"Ian" wrote:
I have adjusted the test with Premiere CS5 Windows 7 64bit ultimate. Even with hardware acceleration is turned off the preview round.


Yes because I understand nothing but merh: What to do with the Comparison of Final Cut Pro and Edius?



Antwort von Axel:

"Gunman" wrote:
Axel, you're wrong: Eidus runs on Windows 7 64 bit but only on 32 bit!

Errare humanum est!


All the more remarkable!



Antwort von Fenek:

So far I have not regretted the purchase of the Edius products.
There were plenty of free updates, so I've decided to be synonymous at some point the update to 6.x.

Plus points:
The PC is much cheaper than purchasing an apple computer.
Edius has no preference whether it is installed with XP or Win7
It is just as fast, which means:
you have to pay to use is not necessarily the latest software version of "micro soft" /!
As one can save like it ....
I find the price offered synonymous absolutely ok for performance.
When burned MSP-user (Media Studio Pro) at the time
So now I am completely satisfied.
The performance is with a regular system the way very well.
The one time synonymous procures an additional product that is reflected in the run-time.
For me it was the Vistitler.
A very fine product! As you can already do a lot with.

PS:
Thanks dongle I can use the product on multiple machines, just take the dongle, done: D




Antworten zu ähnlichen Fragen:
Final Cut suddenly choppy?
How much memory is max. support of Final Cut?
MacPro 1.1 Final Cut system load question
Final Cut. S.PC edit mov
iMovie11 or Final Cut Express for Mac
Final Cut Express 3.5
Please buckle up - is Final Cut update in early 2011?
Final Cut Tutorials
Media 100i - Final Cut 7
Final Cut hangs shortly after booting
the record time set / final cut
Final Cut Express - Exortieren to MOV or MP4? What's faster?
Cut with Final Cut Pro X: Second World War Epic Movie 'Unknown Soldier' Breaks Finland Box Office Record.
Final Cut X
final cut x - Doku :D
Final Cut Pro X 10.3.1
Final Cut ruckelt :(
Final cut showreel
Workflow Final Cut Pro X
Final Cut Layout zurücksetzen
Cinema look, Final Cut pro X
Final Cut 7 kann 4K! Oder
Schönere Texteinblendungen in Final Cut X
Fragen zu Final Cut Pro X
Alter Macbook Final Cut Pro
Final Cut Studio 2.0 unter Mac Os X 10.5 ?

















weitere Themen:
Spezialthemen


16:9
ARD
AVCHD
AVI
Adobe After Effects
Adobe Premiere Pro
After effects
Apple Final Cut Pro
Audio
Avid
Cam
Camcorder
Camera
Canon
Capture
Capturing
Clip
EOS
Editing
Effect
Error
Export
File
Files
Film
Final Cut
Format
Formate
HDR
Import
JVC
Layer
Light
MAGIX video deLuxe
Magix
Microphone
Monitor
Movie
PC
Panasonic
Pinnacle
Pinnacle Studio
Player
Premiere
RAM
RED
Recording
Red
Software
Sony
Sound
Studio
TV
Tape
Video
Videos



update am 16.September 2019 - 18:02
slashCAM
ist ein Projekt der channelunit GmbH
*Datenschutzhinweis*